Map of life expectancy at birth from Global Education Project.

Saturday, April 09, 2022

War is a crime

The concept of "war crimes" is ridiculous. In case you didn't know it, the principal charges at the Nuremberg trials were plotting and carrying out invasions -- committing an illegal war of aggression. How the defendants specifically waged war was not the issue. And by the way, the allied countries indiscriminately bombed cities for the precise purpose of massacring civilians -- as depicted by Kurt Vonnegut in Slaughterhouse Five.


During the U.S. invasion and occupation of Iraq and Afghanistan, U.S. generals spoke frequently of what they call "collateral damage." This is when they bomb wedding parties, as seemed to happen routinely, or when they bombed and destroyed the Doctors Without Borders hospital in Kunduz, killing 42 people:

 

Starting at 2:08am on Saturday 3 October, a United States AC-130 gunship fired 211 shells on the main hospital building where patients were sleeping in their beds or being operated on in the operating theatre. At least 42 people were killed, including 24 patients, 14 staff and 4 caretakers. Thirty-seven people were injured.

Our patients burned in their beds, our medical staff were decapitated or lost limbs. Others were shot from the air while they fled the burning building. The attack from the air lasted for around one hour. The main hospital building came under precise and repeated airstrikes, while the surrounding buildings were left mostly untouched.

Throughout the airstrikes our teams desperately called military authorities to stop the attack.

No-one was prosecuted for this. It was collateral damage. Here's the thing. If you start a war, even if you don't behave with the deliberate depravity of Russian troops in Ukraine, you will kill and main innocent civilians.  That will happen inevitably because when you start dropping bombs and shooting you're going to blow up or kill the wrong people sometimes. To say that you didn't do it on purpose is not a moral defense, because you knew that it would be the result of your actions.


I'm not trying to argue that there is full equivalence between the actions of Russia in Ukraine and the actions of the U.S. in Iraq, but it isn't really a difference worth quibbling over. Don't commit illegal wars of aggression, any way you want to do it. To try to define a righteous or honorable or legal way of waging war is ridiculous. War is a crime.

 

Dear dipshits: This isn't about "hating America." It's just the actual, God's honest truth. This happened. "Loving America" would not mean denying the truth.

 

Fucking morons.

Also, too I am obviously not saying that U.S. involvement in WWII was wrong. I am saying that the concept of a war crime is not very meaningful, since the U.S. did in WWII precisely what is being called a war crime by Russia now. However, Russia initiated this war. That is the fundamental crime. Once you've crossed that threshold, further distinctions are not very important. As for the Civil War, the southern states were committing a crime against humanity. On similar grounds, allied actions in WWII must be judged very leniently.



 

 

Thursday, April 07, 2022

Don't call the police

We've seen far too many stories of people calling 911 because a family member or neighbor is having a behavioral health crisis  -- a psychotic break, a meth overdose, suicidal -- and the police show up and shoot and kill the person. They're allowed to do that, they feel endangered don't you know.

 

Denver has a program called Support Team Assisted Response,  which instead of armed police dispatches EMTs and behavioral health clinicians to these situations.

  • STAR has responded to 2,294 calls for service that would have otherwise been dispatched to police
  • STAR has never called for police back up due to a safety issue

Emphasis mine. These responders are trained to deal with people who are experiencing this sort of crisis. Police are not. That's 2,294 calls to which the police did not need to respond.  So yes, you can take some money out of the police budget and put it here instead. I just won't use the D word.

Wednesday, April 06, 2022

Wednesday Bible Study: Architectural Digest

Chapter 7 describes Solomon's palace, which as I noted before is 4 times bigger than the Temple and takes almost twice as long to build. Make what you will of that. While the First Temple probably existed, the lack of archaeological evidence for it is not surprising since the Temple Mount cannot be excavated. However, no such excuse exists for this structure. Remains of a defensive city wall from about 1,000 BC have been found in Jerusalem, but this is not evidence for the existence of the palace as some people want to claim. In fact there is no archaeological evidence for the existence of a king Solomon; there are no inscriptions or writings with his name other than this book. 


The only apparent reason for reciting all these grandiose details of the palace is the reason animating all of the story of Solomon so far: to aggrandize his person and kingdom to the point of absurdity. The 700 wives and 300 concubines, including a marriage to Pharaoh's daughter; the ridiculous numbers of horses and chariots and men under arms; the preposterous tribute paid to him; all of this is to create a myth of a glorious national past. I'm not sure of the motivation for this since it makes the present seem shabby and, as we shall see, Solomon will abandon Yahweh and all of this will be destroyed. 


Some people make mockery of Solomon's "sea" -- really a big water tank -- being 10 cubits in diameter and 30 in circumference, therefore pi=3. I'll excuse the founding error. Apparently water could be drained out of it into smaller vessels for ritual baths.


7 Solomon was building his own house thirteen years, and he finished his entire house.

2 He built the House of the Forest of Lebanon; its length was a hundred cubits, and its breadth fifty cubits, and its height thirty cubits, and it was built upon three[a] rows of cedar pillars, with cedar beams upon the pillars. 3 And it was covered with cedar above the chambers that were upon the forty-five pillars, fifteen in each row. 4 There were window frames in three rows, and window opposite window in three tiers. 5 All the doorways and windows[b] had square frames, and window was opposite window in three tiers.

6 And he made the Hall of Pillars; its length was fifty cubits, and its breadth thirty cubits; there was a porch in front with pillars, and a canopy before them.

7 And he made the Hall of the Throne where he was to pronounce judgment, even the Hall of Judgment; it was finished with cedar from floor to rafters.[c]

8 His own house where he was to dwell, in the other court back of the hall, was of like workmanship. Solomon also made a house like this hall for Pharaoh’s daughter whom he had taken in marriage.

9 All these were made of costly stones, hewn according to measure, sawed with saws, back and front, even from the foundation to the coping, and from the court of the house of the Lord[d] to the great court. 10 The foundation was of costly stones, huge stones, stones of eight and ten cubits. 11 And above were costly stones, hewn according to measurement, and cedar. 12 The great court had three courses of hewn stone round about, and a course of cedar beams; so had the inner court of the house of the Lord, and the vestibule of the house.

Products of Hiram the Bronzeworker

13 And King Solomon sent and brought Hiram from Tyre. 14 He was the son of a widow of the tribe of Naph′tali, and his father was a man of Tyre, a worker in bronze; and he was full of wisdom, understanding, and skill, for making any work in bronze. He came to King Solomon, and did all his work.

15 He cast two pillars of bronze. Eighteen cubits was the height of one pillar, and a line of twelve cubits measured its circumference; it was hollow, and its thickness was four fingers; the second pillar was the same.[e] 16 He also made two capitals of molten bronze, to set upon the tops of the pillars; the height of the one capital was five cubits, and the height of the other capital was five cubits. 17 Then he made two[f] nets of checker work with wreaths of chain work for the capitals upon the tops of the pillars; a net[g] for the one capital, and a net[h] for the other capital. 18 Likewise he made pomegranates;[i] in two rows round about upon the one network, to cover the capital that was upon the top of the pillar; and he did the same with the other capital. 19 Now the capitals that were upon the tops of the pillars in the vestibule were of lily-work, four cubits. 20 The capitals were upon the two pillars and also above the rounded projection which was beside the network; there were two hundred pomegranates, in two rows round about; and so with the other capital. 21 He set up the pillars at the vestibule of the temple; he set up the pillar on the south and called its name Jachin; and he set up the pillar on the north and called its name Bo′az. 22 And upon the tops of the pillars was lily-work. Thus the work of the pillars was finished.

23 Then he made the molten sea; it was round, ten cubits from brim to brim, and five cubits high, and a line of thirty cubits measured its circumference. 24 Under its brim were gourds, for thirty[j] cubits, compassing the sea round about; the gourds were in two rows, cast with it when it was cast. 25 It stood upon twelve oxen, three facing north, three facing west, three facing south, and three facing east; the sea was set upon them, and all their hinder parts were inward. 26 Its thickness was a handbreadth; and its brim was made like the brim of a cup, like the flower of a lily; it held two thousand baths.

27 He also made the ten stands of bronze; each stand was four cubits long, four cubits wide, and three cubits high. 28 This was the construction of the stands: they had panels, and the panels were set in the frames 29 and on the panels that were set in the frames were lions, oxen, and cherubim. Upon the frames, both above and below the lions and oxen, there were wreaths of beveled work. 30 Moreover each stand had four bronze wheels and axles of bronze; and at the four corners were supports for a laver. The supports were cast, with wreaths at the side of each. 31 Its opening was within a crown which projected upward one cubit; its opening was round, as a pedestal is made, a cubit and a half deep. At its opening there were carvings; and its panels were square, not round. 32 And the four wheels were underneath the panels; the axles of the wheels were of one piece with the stands; and the height of a wheel was a cubit and a half. 33 The wheels were made like a chariot wheel; their axles, their rims, their spokes, and their hubs, were all cast. 34 There were four supports at the four corners of each stand; the supports were of one piece with the stands. 35 And on the top of the stand there was a round band half a cubit high; and on the top of the stand its stays and its panels were of one piece with it. 36 And on the surfaces of its stays and on its panels, he carved cherubim, lions, and palm trees, according to the space of each, with wreaths round about. 37 After this manner he made the ten stands; all of them were cast alike, of the same measure and the same form.

38 And he made ten lavers of bronze; each laver held forty baths, each laver measured four cubits, and there was a laver for each of the ten stands. 39 And he set the stands, five on the south side of the house, and five on the north side of the house; and he set the sea at the southeast corner of the house.

40 Hiram also made the pots, the shovels, and the basins. So Hiram finished all the work that he did for King Solomon on the house of the Lord: 41 the two pillars, the two bowls of the capitals that were on the tops of the pillars, and the two networks to cover the two bowls of the capitals that were on the tops of the pillars; 42 and the four hundred pomegranates for the two networks, two rows of pomegranates for each network, to cover the two bowls of the capitals that were upon the pillars; 43 the ten stands, and the ten lavers upon the stands; 44 and the one sea, and the twelve oxen underneath the sea.

45 Now the pots, the shovels, and the basins, all these vessels in the house of the Lord, which Hiram made for King Solomon, were of burnished bronze. 46 In the plain of the Jordan the king cast them, in the clay ground between Succoth and Zarethan. 47 And Solomon left all the vessels unweighed, because there were so many of them; the weight of the bronze was not found out.

48 So Solomon made all the vessels that were in the house of the Lord: the golden altar, the golden table for the bread of the Presence, 49 the lampstands of pure gold, five on the south side and five on the north, before the inner sanctuary; the flowers, the lamps, and the tongs, of gold; 50 the cups, snuffers, basins, dishes for incense, and firepans, of pure gold; and the sockets of gold, for the doors of the innermost part of the house, the most holy place, and for the doors of the nave of the temple.

51 Thus all the work that King Solomon did on the house of the Lord was finished. And Solomon brought in the things which David his father had dedicated, the silver, the gold, and the vessels, and stored them in the treasuries of the house of the Lord.

Footnotes

  1. 1 Kings 7:2 Gk: Heb four
  2. 1 Kings 7:5 Gk: Heb posts
  3. 1 Kings 7:7 Syr Vg: Heb floor
  4. 1 Kings 7:9 With 7.12: Heb from the outside
  5. 1 Kings 7:15 Tg Syr Compare Gk and Jer 52.21: Heb and a line of twelve cubits measured the circumference of the second pillar
  6. 1 Kings 7:17 Gk: Heb lacks he made two
  7. 1 Kings 7:17 Gk: Heb seven
  8. 1 Kings 7:17 Gk: Heb seven
  9. 1 Kings 7:18 With 2 Mss Compare Gk: Heb pillars
  10. 1 Kings 7:24 Heb ten

Sunday, April 03, 2022

Follow up on Deep Thoughts

Paul Campos explains why ignorance and stupidity have become a feature, not a bug, for conservatives, in a post titled The Cult of Stupidity. This is pretty much what I was trying to say in my previous post, but he spells out the details more clearly. I hope he won't mind quoting at length:


(1) Hatred of intellectuals in general, and academics in particular. Anti-intellectualism in American life is as old as the Republic, but has certainly gotten more overtly intense in the Trump era. In fact in mainstream American cultural discourse, let alone on the explicit right wing, the very word “intellectual” is more than faintly ridiculous and disreputable, to the point where it’s almost a requirement that it be preceded by the modifier “so-called.”

(2) Citations to “common sense,” as an antidote to the absurd things intellectuals believe. Bari Weiss’s SubStack is called Common Sense, which is an example of how anybody who cites common sense as a core principle of intellectual life is either a grifter, or a fool, or more likely both.

(3) Dogmatic belief in some sort of fundamentalist religion, usually evangelical Protestantism, but sometimes the most reactionary forms of Catholicism. Religious fundamentalism is incompatible with intellectual life, which more than any other single reason accounts for why the base of the Republican party is as a matter of first principles opposed to any form of genuine critical inquiry.

(4) Class resentment. This is a complex factor, but graduating from college, and most especially an elite college, is still an important marker of upper middle or upper class status, which means that for many people, especially white working and middle class religious fundamentalists, the primary formal institutions of intellectual life in America elicit deep feelings of class envy and anger. (This factor leads to the amusing contortions of so many upper class Republican politicians to present themselves as Plain Country Folk to the voters, in a desperate attempt to get those voters to forget that these politicians are in fact first and foremost themselves upper class defenders of the plutocracy.)

(5) The rise of internet autodidacts, who have done their own research, and don’t need communist sympathizers with fancy degrees who buy $30 per pound exotic cheeses at Whole Foods to explain things to people who are dead set on making up their own minds, after they look at the evidence themselves, instead of depending on some so-called “experts” to tell them what to believe.

Note number 3 in particular. The point is, if you believe that, you can believe anything.



Sunday Sermonette: Design specifications

Chapter 6 is just a detailed description of the temple. I don't know why we're supposed to care about all these architectural and decorative details, and I don't really have anything to say about it. Two points, however. In the following chapters Solomon builds his own palace, and it's more than 4 times as big (5,000 square cubits vs. 1,200 square cubits, i.e. 1,040 square meters vs. 250 square meters). Also, the calculation of the years since the exodus is wrong. I'll just quote SAB:


After the Israelites left Egypt, they wandered in the wilderness for 40 years. When they arrived in Israel, they were ruled by judges for 450 years. Then Saul was made king and he ruled for 40 years. The next king was David who ruled for the usual 40 years. After David died, Solomon became king, 570 (40+450+40+40) years after the Israelites left Egypt.

So, four years into Solomon's reign is 574 years after the exodus, not 480. Not that anyone should care.

 

6 In the four hundred and eightieth year after the people of Israel came out of the land of Egypt, in the fourth year of Solomon’s reign over Israel, in the month of Ziv, which is the second month, he began to build the house of the Lord. 2 The house which King Solomon built for the Lord was sixty cubits long, twenty cubits wide, and thirty cubits high. 3 The vestibule in front of the nave of the house was twenty cubits long, equal to the width of the house, and ten cubits deep in front of the house. 4 And he made for the house windows with recessed frames. 5 He also built a structure against the wall of the house, running round the walls of the house, both the nave and the inner sanctuary; and he made side chambers all around. 6 The lowest story[a] was five cubits broad, the middle one was six cubits broad, and the third was seven cubits broad; for around the outside of the house he made offsets on the wall in order that the supporting beams should not be inserted into the walls of the house.

7 When the house was built, it was with stone prepared at the quarry; so that neither hammer nor axe nor any tool of iron was heard in the temple, while it was being built.

8 The entrance for the lowest[b] story was on the south side of the house; and one went up by stairs to the middle story, and from the middle story to the third. 9 So he built the house, and finished it; and he made the ceiling of the house of beams and planks of cedar. 10 He built the structure against the whole house, each story[c] five cubits high, and it was joined to the house with timbers of cedar.

11 Now the word of the Lord came to Solomon, 12 “Concerning this house which you are building, if you will walk in my statutes and obey my ordinances and keep all my commandments and walk in them, then I will establish my word with you, which I spoke to David your father. 13 And I will dwell among the children of Israel, and will not forsake my people Israel.”

14 So Solomon built the house, and finished it. 15 He lined the walls of the house on the inside with boards of cedar; from the floor of the house to the rafters[d] of the ceiling, he covered them on the inside with wood; and he covered the floor of the house with boards of cypress. 16 He built twenty cubits of the rear of the house with boards of cedar from the floor to the rafters,[e] and he built this within as an inner sanctuary, as the most holy place. 17 The house, that is, the nave in front of the inner sanctuary, was forty cubits long. 18 The cedar within the house was carved in the form of gourds and open flowers; all was cedar, no stone was seen. 19 The inner sanctuary he prepared in the innermost part of the house, to set there the ark of the covenant of the Lord. 20 The inner sanctuary[f] was twenty cubits long, twenty cubits wide, and twenty cubits high; and he overlaid it with pure gold. He also made[g] an altar of cedar. 21 And Solomon overlaid the inside of the house with pure gold, and he drew chains of gold across, in front of the inner sanctuary, and overlaid it with gold. 22 And he overlaid the whole house with gold, until all the house was finished. Also the whole altar that belonged to the inner sanctuary he overlaid with gold.

The Furnishings of the Temple

23 In the inner sanctuary he made two cherubim of olivewood, each ten cubits high. 24 Five cubits was the length of one wing of the cherub, and five cubits the length of the other wing of the cherub; it was ten cubits from the tip of one wing to the tip of the other. 25 The other cherub also measured ten cubits; both cherubim had the same measure and the same form. 26 The height of one cherub was ten cubits, and so was that of the other cherub. 27 He put the cherubim in the innermost part of the house; and the wings of the cherubim were spread out so that a wing of one touched the one wall, and a wing of the other cherub touched the other wall; their other wings touched each other in the middle of the house. 28 And he overlaid the cherubim with gold.

29 He carved all the walls of the house round about with carved figures of cherubim and palm trees and open flowers, in the inner and outer rooms. 30 The floor of the house he overlaid with gold in the inner and outer rooms.

31 For the entrance to the inner sanctuary he made doors of olivewood; the lintel and the doorposts formed a pentagon.[h] 32 He covered the two doors of olivewood with carvings of cherubim, palm trees, and open flowers; he overlaid them with gold, and spread gold upon the cherubim and upon the palm trees.

33 So also he made for the entrance to the nave doorposts of olivewood, in the form of a square, 34 and two doors of cypress wood; the two leaves of the one door were folding, and the two leaves of the other door were folding. 35 On them he carved cherubim and palm trees and open flowers; and he overlaid them with gold evenly applied upon the carved work. 36 He built the inner court with three courses of hewn stone and one course of cedar beams.

37 In the fourth year the foundation of the house of the Lord was laid, in the month of Ziv. 38 And in the eleventh year, in the month of Bul, which is the eighth month, the house was finished in all its parts, and according to all its specifications. He was seven years in building it.

Footnotes

  1. 1 Kings 6:6 Gk: Heb structure
  2. 1 Kings 6:8 Gk Tg: Heb middle
  3. 1 Kings 6:10 Heb lacks each story
  4. 1 Kings 6:15 Gk: Heb walls
  5. 1 Kings 6:16 Gk: Heb walls
  6. 1 Kings 6:20 Vg: Heb and before the inner sanctuary
  7. 1 Kings 6:20 Gk: Heb covered
  8. 1 Kings 6:31 Heb obscure

 

Saturday, April 02, 2022

Deep thoughts

To creatures that evolved on the African savanna, contemporary physicists' understanding of the world is preposterous. Physicists believe a whole lot of stuff that is pointless and ridiculous. I can't say that I understand it very well myself but after a lifetime of subscribing to Scientific American, and reading a few books along the way, I think I have a reasonable intuitive understanding of most of it, and how they got to their conclusions, enough to convince me that they're understanding is progressive.


"Progressive" is the most credit I can give because they will be the first to tell you that there is a whole lot about the world that still baffles them. In fact, they can't account for 95% of the mass-energy content of the universe. Furthermore, much of their current theoretical picture may turn out to be not quite right. Nevertheless they have gotten closer to the truth than ever before, and much of their arcane and counterintuitive knowledge must be correct in some sense because the Global Positioning System and microprocessors, among other technologies, work.


But the vast majority of people don't know anything about quantum chromodynamics or particle entanglement or the general theory of relativity, and if I tried to explain it to them they'd think it was insane. On the other hand I do know a lot about Christianity -- my uncle was a preacher, my mother taught Sunday school, and I went until I was 13. And let me tell you, it is absolutely ridiculous. I won't try to sum up quantum chromodynamics for you but I can sum up Christianity.


In the original version, at some time thousands of years in the past, there were two people in the world. They disobeyed God by eating a piece of fruit, so he condemned all of their descendants to pain and eternal torment after death. (Plain old death is the literal sentence in Genesis, but Christians came up with the idea of hell.) Many modern Christian sects, including the Catholic church, have stopped taking the story about the piece of fruit literally, but in a way that makes it even worse. Humans have been bearing the burden of Original Sin not just for 10,000 years, but for 300,000. (Not clear if Homo erectus had original sin.) Why we were burdened with Original Sin in this more modern telling is not specified.

 

Anyway, after 8,000 or 300,000 years, whichever you like, God decided to fix this situation. So he made a virgin pregnant with his son, who was also himself, and then had his son/self tortured to death except he didn't die, and now if you believe this you don't have to go to hell. If you don't believe it, however, you're still screwed. This was a rough deal for most of the world's people for the next 1,500 years or so, because they never had a chance to hear this story and therefore to believe it. 

 

But most people still don't believe this -- most of them adhere to other, equally ridiculous religions, and a few are like me.  And even the Christians think that most Christians are wrong about the whole thing in some way. There is no actual evidence for any of this, you're just supposed to believe one thing or another, usually whatever your parents told you when you were a child. 


The problem is, if you believe in a religion, you can believe anything. Believing that Donald Trump won the 2020 election is like believing in the resurrection. You just believe it, doesn't matter that it's completely ridiculous. This is a problem. Science has given humanity such power that we absolutely must have a consensual understanding of reality if we are to save ourselves from ourselves. The only way out is through -- science and reason must prevail over superstition and motivated belief if we are to solve the multiple crises we've caused by giving ourselves so much power with too little wisdom. But we're getting there much too slowly.

Thursday, March 31, 2022

The politicization of medication

There's been plenty of ridiculousness in the past few years, but to me -- perhaps influenced by my profession -- one of the greatest absurdities has been the touting of useless and dangerous medications as a partisan political cause. It makes no evident sense in terms of political ideology. There's nothing "conservative" about screaming that a useless medication actually works, or attacking doctors and hospitals for not prescribing it. There was however an insane idiot who was the leader of the Republican cult and he started it. Apparently that's all it takes nowadays.


So let's step back and consider how we determine that medications are safe and effective, and what the standard ought to be for making that decision. We can start with Carl Zimmer in the NYT today. If you have a subscription or a free read left this month you can take a look, but I'll tell you what you need to know in case you don't. First, ivermectin is completely useless against Covid-19. That is the conclusion of a well-conducted, fairly large clinical trial in which 679 people infected with the virus received the chemical and a comparably sized group did not. There was no difference in the risk of hospitalization.


As Zimmer explains:


Early in the pandemic, when researchers were trying thousands of old drugs against Covid-19, laboratory experiments on cells suggested that ivermectin might block the coronavirus. At the time, skeptics pointed out that the experiments worked thanks to high concentrations of the drug — far beyond safe levels for people. Nevertheless, some doctors began prescribing ivermectin for Covid-19, despite a warning from the Food and Drug Administration that it was not approved for such use.

Around the world, researchers carried out small clinical trials to see if the drug treated the disease. In December 2020, Andrew Hill, a virologist at the University of Liverpool in England, reviewed the results of 23 trials and concluded that ivermectin appeared to significantly lower the risk of death from Covid-19.

 

But critics pointed out that many of the studies had a high risk of bias and one was likely fraudulent. When Dr. Hill did a new review that included only higher quality trials, he found no evidence of benefit. Now the large scale trial has confirmed that. This is a consistent pattern in drug discovery. Small scale, weakly designed studies often find evidence of benefit, and it often gets hyped in the news media before large, well-conducted studies have concluded; and they often have negative findings. 


Why does this happen? There are a few reasons. One is that small scale studies may seem to show a benefit just by chance -- if you compare, say, 20 people who get the drug with 20 who don't, that can easily happen even if there is no real benefit. But the studies that do seem to see a benefit will be promoted and get public notice, while those that don't will quietly disappear. This problem is reinforced by cognitive biases. The people who conduct the studies want them to show benefit, as do the patients generally, and there are many ways this bias can subconsciously influence the results. I won't go into all of them here but I think we can all agree that wishful thinking is powerful.


That's why, when they are feasible and ethical, large scale, placebo controlled, double blind randomized trials are considered the gold standard for deciding whether a medication is effective. Double blind means that neither the investigators nor the patients know who is getting the real drug. Large scale means there are enough participants that differences will be unlikely to be due to chance. Randomized means the investigators don't get to choose who will be in the intervention arm. 


There are some problems and limitations with this, to be sure. There may be "heterogeneity of treatment effect," such that the medication benefits some people but harms others, and the effects cancel out. But obviously, until and unless we can sort that out, it doesn't make sense to prescribe the drug. 

 

Actually the problems are usually in the other direction -- there isn't long enough follow-up or sufficient monitoring to detect all the possible adverse side effects. And even in large-scale trials, apparent effects can actually be due to chance. Unfortunately in these cases, historically, the trials showing some effect were more likely to be published. There is also the problem of retrospective analysis, in which investigators look at end points they didn't originally hypothesize. Statistical theory tell us this invalidates any inferences. The FDA and NIH are trying to address this problem by requiring registration of trials in advance. 


In any case, for an unproven drug to be a political cause is ridiculous. I hope it never happens again.

Wednesday, March 30, 2022

Wednesday Bible Study: Construction Contract

The next couple of chapters describe the construction of the first temple. Most scholars think it probably existed, one reason being that its destruction, which is described later, happened within perhaps a generation of whoever wrote this. However, as I have noted earlier, archaeological excavation on the Temple Mount is not possible, so it can't be confirmed by physical evidence. (Archaeological finds which some have claimed to be evidence for the temple have either turned out to be fakes, or are of dubious meaning.) 


In any case, it was highly unlikely to have been as grand as is described here, and we don't know who built it and when. It was almost certainly later than is claimed here because, as I have also noted before, the kingdom at this time, if it really could be called a kingdom at all, did not have the resources for such an undertaking. Nevertheless we are getting to an era where there tend to be more and more grains of truth in the tales. Everything about Solomon's reign is wildly exaggerated if he existed at all, but it's important to the national mythology in a way that earlier stories are not, because it's so tied to a specific place. Note that this continues the Biblical tradition of multiplying numbers by 10 or 100 beyond what is plausible. Note verse 15 et seq. Seventy thousand burden bearers, 80,000 stone cutters and 3,000 construction supervisors for a building of about 250 square meters (see next chapter) would seem to indicate a lot of featherbedding.


5 [a] Now Hiram king of Tyre sent his servants to Solomon, when he heard that they had anointed him king in place of his father; for Hiram always loved David. 2 And Solomon sent word to Hiram, 3 “You know that David my father could not build a house for the name of the Lord his God because of the warfare with which his enemies surrounded him, until the Lord put them under the soles of his feet. 4 But now the Lord my God has given me rest on every side; there is neither adversary nor misfortune. 5 And so I purpose to build a house for the name of the Lord my God, as the Lord said to David my father, ‘Your son, whom I will set upon your throne in your place, shall build the house for my name.’ 6 Now therefore command that cedars of Lebanon be cut for me; and my servants will join your servants, and I will pay you for your servants such wages as you set; for you know that there is no one among us who knows how to cut timber like the Sido′nians.”

7 When Hiram heard the words of Solomon, he rejoiced greatly, and said, “Blessed be the Lord this day, who has given to David a wise son to be over this great people.” 8 And Hiram sent to Solomon, saying, “I have heard the message which you have sent to me; I am ready to do all you desire in the matter of cedar and cypress timber. 9 My servants shall bring it down to the sea from Lebanon; and I will make it into rafts to go by sea to the place you direct, and I will have them broken up there, and you shall receive it; and you shall meet my wishes by providing food for my household.” 10 So Hiram supplied Solomon with all the timber of cedar and cypress that he desired, 11 while Solomon gave Hiram twenty thousand cors of wheat as food for his household, and twenty thousand[b] cors of beaten oil. Solomon gave this to Hiram year by year. 12 And the Lord gave Solomon wisdom, as he promised him; and there was peace between Hiram and Solomon; and the two of them made a treaty.

13 King Solomon raised a levy of forced labor out of all Israel; and the levy numbered thirty thousand men. 14 And he sent them to Lebanon, ten thousand a month in relays; they would be a month in Lebanon and two months at home; Adoni′ram was in charge of the levy. 15 Solomon also had seventy thousand burden-bearers and eighty thousand hewers of stone in the hill country, 16 besides Solomon’s three thousand three hundred chief officers who were over the work, who had charge of the people who carried on the work. 17 At the king’s command, they quarried out great, costly stones in order to lay the foundation of the house with dressed stones. 18 So Solomon’s builders and Hiram’s builders and the men of Gebal did the hewing and prepared the timber and the stone to build the house.

Footnotes

  1. 1 Kings 5:1 Ch 5.15 in Heb
  2. 1 Kings 5:11 Gk: Heb twenty



Monday, March 28, 2022

No, it isn't over

The country as a whole, including apparently the CDC, has decided that the Covid-19 thing is over and done with. The Republicans in congress even insisted on stripping funding for Covid-19 testing and relief from the recent appropriation bill, and the Democrats went along with little protest. 

 

While it is true that most of the country right now is experiencing a lull, there has been a bump up in hospitalizations in Europe. Look at the far right of the chart:

 


 

As you can see the uptick so far is small, but it's just beginning. It's because of the new Omicron BA.2 variant, which is more transmissible than the previously prevalent Omicron variant and can infect people who have had previous infections and vaccination. Again, vaccination greatly reduces the risk of severe disease, bu vaccinated people can still get sick. The virus will continue to mutate, and there is no way to predict whether a future variant will cause more severe illness, or will be even better able to evade prior immunity, but there's no reason to assume it won't do either.


As Katherine J. Wu discusses in The Atlantic, we are totally unprepared for another surge. Not only do we have the political problem that a substantial proportion of the population will refuse to go along with mitigation measures or get vaccinated, we do not have the resources to respond. CDC has also decided that it won't recommend mitigation measures until hospitalizations and deaths are already at a critical level. No, I don't know what will happen, maybe this won't be so bad, or the worst will be localized. But the depth of denial in this country is just terrifying. 


Let me remind you that you want no part of this virus. "Mild disease" now means you don't end up in the hospital, but take it from me, that doesn't necessarily mean it's what you would consider mild. And something like 20-30% of people who get "mild" disease end up with symptoms that last for months, or maybe forever, and recent research finds they have an elevated risk of dying in the next six months. It can really knock the crap out of you. No, it isn't just like the flu.