Map of life expectancy at birth from Global Education Project.

Wednesday, December 08, 2004

"Race" and ethnicity

A major problem with the way people nowadays talk about health disparities -- and many other areas of inequality -- is confusion about the biological and social meanings of race and ethnicity. The U.S. is still a racist society, by which I mean that people believe in the reality of "race" both as a biological phenomenon and an organizing principle for social advocacy -- whether they are white supremacists or, unfortunately in too many cases, Black academics.

Ethnicity refers to group identity within a larger society, often connected with cultural differences and sometimes reinforced by socially accepted beliefs about the significance of certain physical traits. Such prejudices about physical differences underlie the construction of social “races.” The scientific consensus does not doubt that certain variant genes differed in frequency in different places in ancient times. However, it rejects the socially constructed concepts of race that pervade society. African Americans are a very real ethnic group, but very few African Americans are of exclusively African ancestry, and many people who are not ethnically African American have a higher proportion of African ancestry than many African Americans. Pakistanis, Chinese, and Filipinos are all aggregated into a putative “Asian” race, but this is as nonsensical biologically as it is socially. Examples are endless.

It must also be said that the notion that humanity was once divided into five reproductively isolated, independently evolving groups is obviously false. Native Americans came from Asia in evolutionarily very recent times. Africans, Europeans, and Southwest Asians were never reproductively isolated, rather their genes and populations flowed and intermingled along gradients. The genes of Africans flowed into Europe throughout history, and vice versa. (Remember Antony and Cleopatra, Othello and Desdemona, or Solomon and the Queen of Sheba?) The construction of five races from gene frequencies, physical traits, or anything else, is largely arbitrary. Pick a different set of characteristics as dispositive, and you get a different set of races.

The differences in health status that correlate with ethnicity – or “race,” if one bases analysis on racial categories – have much to do with social phenomena and little to do with genes. These include socio-economic status and access to opportunities, prejudice and discrimination, differing physical environments, cultural differences in diet and other behaviors that affect health, and many other factors including some as yet unknown. Whatever the importance of sickle cell anemia, Black people in the United States do not have shorter life expectancies than white people because of their genes.

Ethnicity, culture, group identity -- these are socially constructed but are real social phenomena. Race, as a biological concept, is also socially constructed but entirely false. Never forget this.

10 comments:

Anonymous said...

Two random comments to back you up:

- There is vastly more genetic diversity between any two housecats than there are between any two human beings. The darkest-skinned man in Africa is genetically more similar to the blondest Swede than two Siamese cats are to one another.

- One of the reasons the Australian Aborigines were (and continue to be) so poorly treated is that it was assumed that they were Africans. Genetic tests now show that not only are the Aborigines in fact Polynesians, but because of their isolation over millennia, genetically they're more distantly related to Africans than our Swedish friend above.

And, of course, we are all Africans in our genes, since the "Out of Africa" theory of human evolution seems to be the most viable one.

-- Mnemosyne

Cervantes said...

Thanks Mnemosyne. (I believe you are one of the muses, correct.) Of course, the assumption that Aborigines are African is due to their pigmentation, which just shows that the criteria used to label the "races" are certain arbitrary physical characteristics. These do not correlate much with other genetic characteristics that have had geographic gradients in the past. Pick different sets of characteristics to use as indicators, you get different races. But people seized on the most visible and simple, which is principally skin color.

Kevin said...

牙醫,植牙,矯正,紋身,刺青,創業,批發,皮膚科,痘痘,中醫,飛梭雷射,毛孔粗大,醫學美容,seo,關鍵字行銷,關鍵字自然排序,網路行銷,關鍵字自然排序,關鍵字行銷seo,關鍵字廣告,部落格行銷,網路行銷,seo,關鍵字行銷,關鍵字廣告,關鍵字,自然排序,部落格行銷,網路行銷,網路爆紅,牛舌餅婚紗台中婚紗,腳臭,腳臭,腳臭,腳臭,中古車,二手車,中古車,二手車,高雄婚紗,減肥,瘦身 ,搬家,搬家公司,服飾批發,團體服,街舞

Anonymous said...

flagyl achat
acheter xenical en france
amoxil Kaufen
strattera Rezeptfrei Kaufen
levitra Kaufen
Achat lamisil Sans Ordonnance
kamagra Bestellen
priligy Ohne Rezept Kaufen
effexor xr Ohne Rezept
strattera Bestellen Online
Buy proscar
cialis Kaufen
plavix Bestellen Rezeptfrei
plavix acheter

kamagra gel said...

I think that the information is really good, thanks for sharing I think that The differences in health status that correlate with ethnicit!! congregates for the work!!22dd

muebles en valdemoro said...

This can't have effect in reality, that's what I think.

Anonymous said...

Viagra Super Active discount
Zovirax vendita italia
Cialis Professional senza ricetta in farmacia
Keflex españa
achat Silagra
Silagra vendita italia
Priligy france pharmacie
Viagra Soft comprar
Proscar france pharmacie
Nolvadex comprar
acheter Accutane en ligne
Suhagra senza ricetta
precio Celebrex
Cipro españa
Cialis Soft comprar online
prezzo Viagra
Wellbutrin Sr precio
Vigora prix en france
Avodart france
Zithromax france pharmacie
Kamagra Oral Jelly senza ricetta in farmacia
comprar Cialis Soft
comprare Lexapro online
comprar Plavix
Priligy prix
comprar Proscar

Marjorie said...

In my view everyone have to glance at it.

Anonymous said...


Viagra Pharmacie

Acheter Viagra

Anonymous said...


pinicle casino st louis
memory slot colors
dvd player with sd memory card slot
monivision slot monitor
slots sinle line or multiple lines
cf card in sd slot
casino reading
best casino boats fl
casino marriott courtyard san juan
casino free play poker tip
video slots new
smart car and blackjack turbo
choctaw casino oklahoma
berry cherry slot
rx3600 ab036b pci slot configuration
casino line play
disadvantages about slot machines
additional guild wars character slots
slot car sell my car