Map of life expectancy at birth from Global Education Project.

Thursday, January 13, 2005

The Rule of Rescue

It has no doubt occurred to readers that there are some knotty ethical problems underlying some of the issues we have discussed recently. In The Silent Tsunami I pointed out that 29,000 children around the world, mostly in poor countries, die every day from readily preventable causes -- a tusnami's worth every two or three days -- but that there is no outpouring of media attention, public or private donations, or aircraft carriers heading out to rescue them. In The Crux of the Matter I pointed out that we'll readily spend hundreds of thousands of dollars on organ transplants and other procedures that may give a few months of limited life to someone, while we don't spend much smaller sums that could prevent many cases of premature illness and death.

There are many comparable situations. A caravan city of TV vans will materialize in some country town when a child falls down a well. Although children suffer accidents every day, we can't predict which ones it will happen to and we pay little attention when it does.

Consider the case of Belynda Dunn, a 42 year old woman who worked as a health educator and counselor for AIDS Action Committee. She was infected with HIV and Hepatitis C Virus (HCV).
[1] Her physician determined that she had end-stage liver disease. He told her that she would die within a few months without a liver transplant.

However, Ms. Dunn's insurance company, Neighborhood Health Plan, refused to pay for the transplant, on the grounds that the procedure was experimental in people with HIV. NHP is a non-profit company that does most of its business with MassHealth, the state's publicly funded insurance program which covers Medicaid beneficiaries and people who are eligible for other public health insurance programs such as the Supplemental Children's Health Insurance Program. NHP also has commercial clients, mostly non-profit organizations like AIDS Action Committee that purchase coverage for their employees.


The next day, Aids Action Committee called a press conference to denounce the decision. Boston Mayor Tom Menino announced the creation of a fund called the Belynda Dunn Life Fund, to pay for Ms. Dunn's transplant and, he said, others in similar circumstances. NHP then contributed $100,000 to the fund, toward an estimated total cost of $250,000-300,000. Other donors soon brought the fund up to over $200,000. Speaking from her hospital bed, Ms. Dunn told reporters, "It isn't right that an insurance company can decide whether someone lives or dies." Later, it developed that the amount needed was actually $500,000. The surgery would not be performed unless the full amount could be raised. Ms. Dunn's supporters continued to campaign to raise the money, or force the insurance company to pay. As it turned out, in the end a suitable donor could not be found and Ms. Dunn died.

Now, for $500,000, many cases of HIV could be prevented, and for that matter, most if not all of the 29,000 children who died avoidably on the same day Belynda Dunn died could have been saved. But neither Mayor Menino, AIDS Action Committee, Neighborhood Health Plan, or the donors to Ms. Dunn's charitable fund thought to help them. And consider this -- if NHP had paid the $500,000 for Ms. Dunn's liver transplant, where would the money have come from? It would have meant that several hundred poor children could not be covered by the SCHIP program (which is not an entitlement but has a budgetary limit).

A.R. Jonsen, in 1986, coined the term "The Rule of Rescue." John McKie and Jeff Richardson succinctly define this as "The imperative to rescue identifiable individuals facing avoidable death, without giving much thought to the opportunity cost of doing so." Note the key phrase, "identifiable individuals." Statistics don't move us. Those 29,000 children dying every day are scattered around the world. We don't know who they are, we don't know where to find them. In the tsunami, however, the dead and injured and orphaned children were all conveniently piled up together where TV reporters could find them and cameras could film them, just as they could interview Belynda Dunn but could not identify which children would be denied insurance by NHP because of her liver transplant.

So how about this. Is it wrong to let an identifiable suffer or die who it is possible to save? Was NHP wrong to refuse to pay for the procedure? Were they callous, were they inhumane? Is there a way out of this problem?

I'm asking, not telling.




[1] People are often co-infected with these two viruses, which have similar modes of transmission. HCV infection is usually incurable, but the virus can remain latent and not cause problems for some time. When the disease does progress, it can destroy the liver, as in Ms. Dunn's case.

10 comments:

Anonymous said...

viagra Rezeptfrei Kaufen
clomid acheter en ligne
lasix Rezeptfrei Bestellen
diflucan Rezeptfrei Kaufen
Prix zithromax Pharmacie
xenical Rezeptfrei Kaufen
accutane Bestellen
achat kamagra oral jelly en ligne
lasix Ohne Rezept
Rezeptfrei cialis

catalogo puertas metalicas said...

Quite useful data, thank you for this article.

muebles rivas vaciamadrid said...

Hey, there is so much worthwhile info above!

Anonymous said...

comprare Amoxil online
Apcalis Oral Jelly vendita italia
achat Levaquin en ligne
Viagra prezzo farmacia
Synthroid vendita online
Zithromax bestellen
comprar Amoxil sin receta
Flagyl vendita online
Suhagra france pharmacie
Tadacip sin receta
Vigora prezzo farmacia
Kamagra vendita
acheter Synthroid en ligne
Silagra precio
Propecia prix
Viagra Super Active prix en france
Levaquin comprar
acheter Kamagra moins cher
Silagra senza ricetta
Silagra precio farmacia
achat Cialis Soft en ligne
acheter Cialis
Female Viagra rezeptfrei bestellen
precio Viagra Super Active
Viagra Soft vendita online
Neurontin sin receta
Wellbutrin Sr comprar espaƱa

sports handicapping software said...

hello really interesting

Anonymous said...

Achat Viagra Pharmacie
Acheter Viagra France

Anonymous said...


blackjack card games
mental magic roulette
3 isa slot p4 buy
samsung blackjack cingular
bet bet casino draw gambling poker roulette yourbestonlinecasino.com
t slot plate
pictures of blackjack
slots magazine
konami slots strategy
slot machines pay
blackjack java source code
casino free online virtual
fulltilt blackjack
2 nickle slot machine win
casino chicago chicagobestprice.com europe flight hotel online travel usa
mobile blackjack games
blackjack software reviews
coco bongo monte casino
1 32 nascar slot car
join our blackjack team

Muneer Hussian said...

case study solution
case study solution
case study solution
case study solution

case study solution
case study solution
case study solution
case study solution

case study solution
case study solution
case study solution
case study solution

case study solution
case study solution
case study solution
case study solution

case study solution
case study solution
case study solution
case study solution

case study solution
case study solution
case study solution
case study solution

case study solution
case study solution
case study solution
case study solution

case study solution
case study solution
case study solution
case study solution

Calyin Dyol said...

Nice Post Love Reading It

Tadalafil Softgel

JAMES DEAN said...

Thanks for sharing so interesting article with us. I agree with your idea completely. I am looking forward to another great article from you.
Advertising agencies in Karachi | Advertising agencies in Pakistan