Map of life expectancy at birth from Global Education Project.

Friday, November 13, 2009

There will always be an England

A commentary by Tony Delamothe in the new BMJ led me to an interesting editorial from earlier this year in the Journal of Psychopharmacology, by DJ Nutt. Alas, this is all closed access, which annoys me no end. Anyway, Nutt is concerned with the relative harms of various drugs of abuse. He writes:

The dangers of equasy were revealed to me as a result of a recent clinical referral of a woman in her early 30’s who had suffered permanent brain damage as a result of equasy-induced brain damage. She had undergone severe personality change that made her more irritable and impulsive, with anxiety and loss of the ability to experience pleasure. There was also a degree of hypofrontality and behavioural disinhibition that had lead to many bad decisions in relationships with poor choice of partners and an unwanted pregnancy. She is unable to work and is unlikely ever to do so again, so the social costs of her brain damage are also very high.

So what was her addiction – what is equasy? It is an addiction that produces the release of adrenaline and endorphins and which is used by many millions of people in the UK including children and young people. The harmful consequences are well
established – about 10 people a year die of it and many more suffer permanent neurological damage as had my patient. It has been estimated that there is a serious adverse event every 350 exposures and these are unpredictable, though more likely in
experienced users who take more risks with equasy. It is also associated with over 100 road traffic accidents per year – often with deaths. Equasy leads to gatherings of users that often are associated with these groups engaging in violent conduct. Dependence, as defined by the need to continue to use, has been accepted by the courts in divorce settlements. Based on these harms, it seems likely that the ACMD would recommend control under the MDAct perhaps as a class A drug given it appears more harmful than ecstasy.


Equasy is, a you may already have guessed, the practice of riding horses. Ecstasy (MDMA) is associated with acute adverse events in 1 out of 10,000 exposures, in other words horseback riding is almost 30 times more dangerous.

Professor Nutt, unfortunately, made a serious mistake. While his analysis is factually correct, it turned out to be politically incorrect. He was summarily dismissed as Chair of the British government's Advisory Council on the Misuse of Drugs, as the Home Secretary was "profoundly disappointed" by the editorial. Nutt responded that "Politicians believe that if they think something, it is true." You can read about the brouhaha here.

The fact is, we just cannot have a rational debate about "drug" policy, either here or in the UK, because ideology consistently trumps truth in this field. Our jails are bursting with people, mostly poor African American and Hispanic men, who are non-violent drug offenders. White people use "drugs" at higher rates, but don't go to jail for it. And believe me, a whole lot of perfectly legal activities are considerably more harmful than use of most illicit drugs. It makes absolutely no sense, in fact it is eroding the fabric of our society.

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

Illegal drugs return more revenue than legal ones (tobaccy, alky, and the endless pills pharma pushes on us) just because they are illegal. The added value is provided by the ‘illegality’ which in a nutshell obliges consumers to pay between 100 and a 1000 times, or even much more, than what the drug or product would ‘cost’ if it was produced in the ordinary way, that is with consequent Gvmt. subsidies, FAO approval, etc. See farm shrimp, corn meal, kiwis, or aspirin...etc.

Millions of ppl, most of them middlemen, earn their living due to the illegality. As the whole circuit is mafia like, powerful ppl can skim huge, totally staggering, sums off the top. Those powerful ppl are not just individual drug runners, you know, those guys with shades, guns, fake uniforms, bodyguards, fancy cars, and garbled accents.

‘Illegal’ drug production is big business, regulated world wide, and (some) Gvmts. are deeply involved.

No change should be expected any time soon.

Ana

homelesschampions said...

Addiction, violence, civil liberties,crack cocaine, poverty, 2010 Olympics, drugs, prostitution, heroin, homelessness; and their impact on Vancouver's Black Eye, The Downtown Eastside.

More than 2 million syringes are handed out free every year. Clean mouthpieces for crack pipes are provided at taxpayers’ expense. Around 4,000 opiate addicts get prescription methadone. Thousands come to the injection site every year.

addiction is a state in which the body relies on a substance for normal functioning and develops physical dependence, as in drug addiction. When the drug or substance on which someone is dependent is suddenly removed, it will cause withdrawal, a characteristic set of signs and symptoms. Addiction is generally associated with increased drug tolerance common usage of the term addiction has spread to include psychological dependence. In this context, the term is used in drug addiction and substance abuse problems

Impelled by the horror show of the Downtown East Side, prodded by activists and convinced by reams of academic studies, the police and city government have agreed to provide hard drug users with their paraphernalia, a place to use it and even, for a few, the drugs themselves.


The Harsh Reality of Drug Addiction

Not for the faint-hearted, this video is graphic and shocking and shows the depths of depravity that the human soul can descend to.

After 11 months of sobriety from cocaine, heroin, methamphetamine and other drugs this individuals mental state has sunk to an almost animal-like existence.

http://www.2010homelesschampions.ca/reality_of_drug_addiction.htm


2010 Homeless Champions supports The Servants of Hope Recovery House

a proven model of recovery recently acknowledged by Operation Phoenix and the Vancouver Province Newspaper

This website is dedicated to telling the stories of the unfortunate individuals living in the Downtown Eastside of Vancouver in the hope that awareness of this problem will spur people to get involved, to let all levels of government know that something has to be done to alleviate this misery rooted in addiction, homelessness and depravity. To point the way to recovery from addiction, which we believe is the root of most of this situation. With the 2010 Olympics coming to Vancouver it is our mandate to record the transition and the extreme changes that are even now occurring and will continue to unfold in the Downtown Eastside.

http://www.2010homelesschampions.ca