Map of life expectancy at birth from Global Education Project.

Thursday, July 20, 2023

The corporatization of medicine: Part One

This will be a multi-part series.

 

The days of independent community hospitals and small physician practices are just about over. Paul Starr’s famous book The Social Transformation of American Medicine tells the story of rise of a “sovereign” medical profession, consisting largely of entrepreneurs who owned their own individual or small group practices and made their living as independent business people. They were generally suspicious of alternative models such as large group practice and salaried employment. But recent decades have been marked by one overarching trend: the consolidation of the medical institution into fewer and fewer, larger and larger entities.[1] Horizontal consolidation means that similar institutions merge into chains. This has included not only hospitals but also nursing homes, dialysis clinics, and other kinds of facilities. Vertical consolidation means that various kinds of facilities are brought into the same firm, mostly meaning hospital chains buying physician practices, nursing homes and so on – which at the same time achieves horizontal consolidation.

Consolidation of hospitals, insurers and physician services goes back to at least the 1990s.[i] A common way of measuring market concentration in an industry is called the Herfindahl-Hirschman Index (HHI),[2] which can range from any arbitrarily low number up to 10,000, representing a monopoly by a single firm. An HHI of 2,500 or greater is considered highly concentrated. A report published in 2017 found that the mean HHI for hospitals and specialty physician groups (per metropolitan statistical area) increased by 5% from 2010 to 2016, and for primary care physician groups by almost 29%, in part because of vertical consolidation, i.e. hospitals buying physician practices.[ii] Large health insurers[iii] have also been buying physician practices as an investment, as have private equity firms[iv][v]. Private equity firms have no pretense to any mission other than making profit for their owners. Not surprisingly, they strategically purchase practices where they can gain market share and pricing power, and private equity acquisitions are associated with price increases and higher expenditures on medical services.[vi]



[1] Concentration of industries into fewer, larger firms is often called “integration,” but that has a different, specific meaning in Medicine. Integrated care refers to provision of behavioral health and other medical services in the same practice, which we’ll discuss later. To avoid confusion, I’ll stick with “consolidation” in the present context.

[2] Calculated by squaring the market share of each firm in a given area and then summing those values. It seems conceptually confusing but look at it this way. If one firm has a total monopoly, that’s 100% market share, and 1002=10,000, the highest possible HHI. If four firms each have 25%, that’s 25X25X4=2,500.



[i] Gaynor M , Ho K , Town RJ . The industrial organization of health-care markets . J Econ Lit . 2015 ; 53 ( 2 ): 235 – 84

[ii] Brent D. Fulton. Health Care Market Concentration Trends In The United States: Evidence And Policy Responses. Health Affairs. 26(9) September 2017.

 

[iii] Reed Abelson. Corporate Giants Buy Up Primary Care Practices at Rapid Pace. The New York Times, May 8, 2023.

 

[iv] Jane M. Zhu, Lynn M. Hua, Daniel Polsky. Private Equity Acquisitions of Physician Medical Groups Across Specialties, 2013-2016. JAMA 2020;323(7):663-665

[v] Praveen Suthrum. Physician practice consolidation: It’s only just begun. STAT News. Feb 27, 2020.

 

[vi] Richard M. Scheffler, Laura Alexander, Brent D. Fulton, and Ola A. Abdelhadi. Monetizing medicine: private equity and competition in physician practice markets. American Antitrust Institute, the Nicholas C. Petris Center on Health Care Markets and Consumer Welfare, University of California, Berkeley, and the Washington Center for Equitable Growth. July 2023. Available at https://www.antitrustinstitute.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/07/AAI-UCB-EG_Private-Equity-I-Physician-Practice-Report_FINAL.pdf [Accessed July 18, 2023]

 

Wednesday, July 19, 2023

Wednesday Bible Study: The plot thickens

There's nothing particularly noteworthy about Ch. 4. It advances the plot and builds suspense. Keep in mind that this story, like the Book of Ruth, is of a different character than the rest of what we have read so far. It's a consciously crafted work of literary fiction. I'm not saying it would get published in The New Yorker, but it does show the rudiments of the art, particularly with plotting. 

Donning sackcloth -- which was apparently made out of goat or camel hair -- is a common way of showing humility before God in the Biblical world. So although God is not mentioned in Esther I suppose this at least suggests that the people have him in mind. The only other point I'll make here is that Esther has an unusual "marriage," in that she hasn't seen her husband for 30 days and will be killed if she approaches him without permission. But that's an emperor for you.


4 When Mordecai learned of all that had been done, he tore his clothes, put on sackcloth and ashes, and went out into the city, wailing loudly and bitterly. 2 But he went only as far as the king’s gate, because no one clothed in sackcloth was allowed to enter it. 3 In every province to which the edict and order of the king came, there was great mourning among the Jews, with fasting, weeping and wailing. Many lay in sackcloth and ashes.

4 When Esther’s eunuchs and female attendants came and told her about Mordecai, she was in great distress. She sent clothes for him to put on instead of his sackcloth, but he would not accept them. 5 Then Esther summoned Hathak, one of the king’s eunuchs assigned to attend her, and ordered him to find out what was troubling Mordecai and why.

6 So Hathak went out to Mordecai in the open square of the city in front of the king’s gate. 7 Mordecai told him everything that had happened to him, including the exact amount of money Haman had promised to pay into the royal treasury for the destruction of the Jews. 8 He also gave him a copy of the text of the edict for their annihilation, which had been published in Susa, to show to Esther and explain it to her, and he told him to instruct her to go into the king’s presence to beg for mercy and plead with him for her people.

9 Hathak went back and reported to Esther what Mordecai had said. 10 Then she instructed him to say to Mordecai, 11 “All the king’s officials and the people of the royal provinces know that for any man or woman who approaches the king in the inner court without being summoned the king has but one law: that they be put to death unless the king extends the gold scepter to them and spares their lives. But thirty days have passed since I was called to go to the king.”

12 When Esther’s words were reported to Mordecai, 13 he sent back this answer: “Do not think that because you are in the king’s house you alone of all the Jews will escape. 14 For if you remain silent at this time, relief and deliverance for the Jews will arise from another place, but you and your father’s family will perish. And who knows but that you have come to your royal position for such a time as this?”

15 Then Esther sent this reply to Mordecai: 16 “Go, gather together all the Jews who are in Susa, and fast for me. Do not eat or drink for three days, night or day. I and my attendants will fast as you do. When this is done, I will go to the king, even though it is against the law. And if I perish, I perish.”

17 So Mordecai went away and carried out all of Esther’s instructions.

Tuesday, July 18, 2023

Hey, indeedy

 Remember Jack Texeira, the Air National Guard member who was sharing top secret documents with his neo-Nazi friends on social media? His lawyers want him released pending trial, and they actually have a point, although it's probably the opposite of the point they intended to make.


In court papers, the defense attorneys argued that Teixeira has no financial ability or incentive to flee, and claimed the government “greatly overexaggerates Mr. Teixeira’s risk to national security.” Teixeira’s lawyers noted that prosecutors did not seek to detain Trump — or his co-defendant, Walt Nauta — even though the former president and his valet “possess extraordinary means to flee the United States.” 

 “Former President Trump and The Trump Organization own properties in multiple foreign countries, and former President Trump has access to a private plane. Yet, the risk of flight posed by their knowledge of national security information, and their abnormal ability to flee, didn’t even result in a request that either surrender their passport,” Teixeira’s lawyers wrote.

Teixeira’s attorneys wrote that the “disparate approach” in these cases — which are both charged under the Espionage Act — shows that the government’s “argument for Mr. Teixeira’s detention on this basis is illusory.”

 

Hmm. What should we think about that?

 

Sunday, July 16, 2023

Sunday Sermonette: A powerful resonance, but an inexact analogy

It's obvious why the Book of Esther and the festival of Purim are important to Judaism today. While the specific events in Esther are fictitious, the story does strongly suggest that even in the first diaspora, in the Persian empire, the Jews faced hostility and discrimination. That they were literally marked for extermination speaks directly to the events of the 20th Century.


There are some lacunae here. The author does not explain why Mordecai would not bow down to Haman, or exactly why Haman transferred his resentment of Mordecai to the entire Jewish people. The empire was multi-ethnic and multi-lingual generally. In what way the Jews' customs were separate that somehow distinguished them from all the other peoples in the empire with distinct customs is not explained. I would note that Haman is apparently proposing to exterminate Jews of the diaspora, but not to attack Judah, which by the emperor's decree has its own customs and is capable of self-defense. So this story provides an obvious template for modern Zionism. Whether a work of fiction that is at least 2,400 years old really constitutes any form of justification is questionable, however. Also, as we shall see, the story turns out differently from the modern story.


3 After these events, King Xerxes honored Haman son of Hammedatha, the Agagite, elevating him and giving him a seat of honor higher than that of all the other nobles. 2 All the royal officials at the king’s gate knelt down and paid honor to Haman, for the king had commanded this concerning him. But Mordecai would not kneel down or pay him honor.

3 Then the royal officials at the king’s gate asked Mordecai, “Why do you disobey the king’s command?” 4 Day after day they spoke to him but he refused to comply. Therefore they told Haman about it to see whether Mordecai’s behavior would be tolerated, for he had told them he was a Jew.

5 When Haman saw that Mordecai would not kneel down or pay him honor, he was enraged. 6 Yet having learned who Mordecai’s people were, he scorned the idea of killing only Mordecai. Instead Haman looked for a way to destroy all Mordecai’s people, the Jews, throughout the whole kingdom of Xerxes.

7 In the twelfth year of King Xerxes, in the first month, the month of Nisan, the pur (that is, the lot) was cast in the presence of Haman to select a day and month. And the lot fell on[a] the twelfth month, the month of Adar.

8 Then Haman said to King Xerxes, “There is a certain people dispersed among the peoples in all the provinces of your kingdom who keep themselves separate. Their customs are different from those of all other people, and they do not obey the king’s laws; it is not in the king’s best interest to tolerate them. 9 If it pleases the king, let a decree be issued to destroy them, and I will give ten thousand talents[b] of silver to the king’s administrators for the royal treasury.”

10 So the king took his signet ring from his finger and gave it to Haman son of Hammedatha, the Agagite, the enemy of the Jews. 11 “Keep the money,” the king said to Haman, “and do with the people as you please.”

12 Then on the thirteenth day of the first month the royal secretaries were summoned. They wrote out in the script of each province and in the language of each people all Haman’s orders to the king’s satraps, the governors of the various provinces and the nobles of the various peoples. These were written in the name of King Xerxes himself and sealed with his own ring. 13 Dispatches were sent by couriers to all the king’s provinces with the order to destroy, kill and annihilate all the Jews—young and old, women and children—on a single day, the thirteenth day of the twelfth month, the month of Adar, and to plunder their goods. 14 A copy of the text of the edict was to be issued as law in every province and made known to the people of every nationality so they would be ready for that day.

15 The couriers went out, spurred on by the king’s command, and the edict was issued in the citadel of Susa. The king and Haman sat down to drink, but the city of Susa was bewildered.

Footnotes

  1. Esther 3:7 Septuagint; Hebrew does not have And the lot fell on.
  2. Esther 3:9 That is, about 375 tons or about 340 metric tons

Friday, July 14, 2023

Mindlessness

Academy Health is the rather oddly named society for health services researchers. They sent me a press release which I excerpt:

 

Today, the House Appropriations Committee released a breathtakingly reckless bill that decimates federal research, science, and medicine programs, and puts the health of all Americans at risk. It is so extreme that many pundits presume it has zero chance of becoming law, but that very extremism requires that we respond quickly and unequivocally.   . . . 

 

"This bill would eliminate the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ) in its entirety. AHRQ supports research to improve health care quality, reduce costs, advance patient safety, decrease medical errors, and broaden access to essential services. Over 150 organizations through the Friends of AHRQ made the case crystal clear – we need more support for this research to meet these challenging times. These organizations represented every corner of the health care world – patients, providers, nurses, hospitals, insurers, health systems, universities, think tanks, and more – emphasizing how noncontroversial it is that we produce the best evidence on how to deliver the best care equitably.

“As rural patients struggle with health care access as their hospitals close and doctors move further away, AHRQ has been a close partner for them. AHRQ formally recognizes rural Americans as a priority health group and focuses on identifying drivers of poor health outcomes, finding connections through telehealth, and tackling the opioid epidemic. Instead of working with AHRQ as it pioneers novel projects and programs for rural Americans, this bill abolishes AHRQ altogether.

“But this bill is not just about eliminating AHRQ, it is also slashing the innovation that makes America competitive and that eliminates health disparities faced by patients for racial, ethnic, geographic, gender, or socioeconomic reasons. It cuts the Advanced Research Projects Agency for Health (ARPA-H) by two thirds. It burns through CDC at a time when we need to be building capacity – eliminating funding for Firearm Injury and Mortality Prevention Research, Tobacco Prevention and Control, Ending the HIV Epidemic initiatives. At a time when public health agencies are calling for more data modernization, it cuts the Public Health Data Modernization program by over 40 percent. It eliminates programs that support needed diversity in the healthcare workforce. It cuts the Office of Minority Health by two thirds.

 

Why are they doing this? What is the constituency for it?  I can answer that but it's a bit complicated. Our medical institution is in big trouble. You see the reference in the press release to hospitals closing and a serious shortage of health care resources in rural areas, but there's much more to it than that. As private equity firms and giant corporations buy up physician practices all over the country, medicine is increasingly driven solely by profit, and physicians are less and less able to treat their patients as human beings and effectively meet their needs. AHRQ funds research that documents health outcomes and develops approaches to providing medical services that improve the nation's health and quality of life. The capitalists who increasingly run the system and fund Republican politicians don't want us to know the truth. Tobacco companies and firearm manufacturers don't want to fund tobacco control or firearm safety. None of these billionaire donors to the Republican party want data systems that will let the American people know the truth about the health and well being of the nation, because we might want to do something about it.


That's your Republican party.


 



Wednesday, July 12, 2023

Let me set the record straight

I received the following comment:


Retraction of scientific articles is associated with well-deserved shame: plagiarism, making up data, or grave concerns about the scientific integrity of a study. But my article was not retracted for any shameful reason. It was retracted because it provided evidence for an idea that activists hate.

There is ample evidence that in progressive communities, multiple girls from the same peer group are announcing they are trans almost simultaneously. There has been a sharp increase in this phenomenon across the industrialized West. A recent review from the UK, which keeps better records than America, showed a greater than tenfold increase in referrals of adolescent girls during just the past decade.

But there have been virtually no scientific data or studies on the subject.

In part that is because researchers who have touched this topic have been punished for their curiosity. Just ask Lisa Littman. Ultimately, her paper on the subject resulted in an unnecessary “correction” by the journal that published it, and the loss of Littman’s academic affiliation with Brown University, which prioritized activist outrage over Littman’s academic freedom.

 

I happen to know a whole lot about the issue concerning Lisa Littman. I am on the faculty of the school of public health with which she was affiliated when she first published the article, and we discussed the incident in a faculty meeting at considerable length. I am also an academic editor of the publication in which it appeared, although I had nothing to do with the specific paper, so I received correspondence about it.

 

Dr. Littman was not "punished for her curiosity," nor was her academic freedom compromised in any way, nor did PLOS ONE publish an "unnecessary correction."  What happened is that she interviewed people who participate in an on-line support group for parents who do not accept their children's representation that they are trans-gender, and specifically who perceived their trans-gendering as "sudden onset," and accepted what the respondents told her at face value. She did not interview any of the children, or their clinicians, or anyone who is transgender, which simply means that her conclusions about the reality of this phenomenon are dubious. The parents may have failed to perceive their children's feelings until the children announced them; the parents had difficulty accepting this; and they therefore concluded, erroneously, that some external influence may have made the children say this when it had no antecedent in their actual experience.


In other words, the article made an unsupported inference. Many people wrote to the editors to point this out, whereupon they conducted a review of the article with both senior editorial staff and outside consultants. They then asked the author to respond to the concerns raised in this process, which she did by revising the article, which they then republished. The Editors' conclusions, which you may read here (with considerable additional discussion), were:


This study of parent observations and interpretations serves to develop the hypotheses that rapid-onset gender dysphoria is a phenomenon and that social influences, parent-child conflict, and maladaptive coping mechanisms may be contributing factors for some individuals. Rapid-onset gender dysphoria (ROGD) is not a formal mental health diagnosis at this time. This report did not collect data from the adolescents and young adults (AYAs) or clinicians and therefore does not validate the phenomenon. Additional research that includes AYAs, along with consensus among experts in the field, will be needed to determine if what is described here as rapid-onset gender dysphoria (ROGD) will become a formal diagnosis. Furthermore, the use of the term, rapid-onset gender dysphoria should be used cautiously by clinicians and parents to describe youth who appear to fall into this category. The term should not be used in a way to imply that it explains the experiences of all gender dysphoric youth nor should it be used to stigmatize vulnerable individuals. This article has been revised to better reflect that these parent reports provide information that can be used to develop hypotheses about factors that may contribute to the onset and/or expression of gender dysphoria among this demographic group.

 

It is common in scholarly publication for initial reviews to fail to catch problems with a paper. Journals commonly -- as in several times every day, actually -- either publish corrections, as in this case, or retract articles that are fatally flawed. There is nothing in the least unusual about this incident and it was not based on "activist outrage" but on sound scientific method and reasoning.


Littman was a non-tenure track research professor on a time-limited contract. Perhaps unfortunately, it is common for people in that situation not to have their contracts renewed. There are many factors involved -- for one thing, people in that situation are responsible for bringing in funding to support their position. I do not know why Littman is no longer on the faculty, or whether this specific incident had anything to do with it. To my understanding her mentors viewed this as a mistake by an inexperienced investigator and treated her supportively. Certainly in the faculty meeting people were sympathetic. The real fault here lies with the initial peer reviewers, who should have given her appropriate feedback and allowed her to revise the paper before it was published. The subsequent correction was entirely necessary and appropriate.

Wednesday Bible Study: Cattle call (or, Here she is, Miss Achaemenid)

I'd be interested in hearing the reactions of some women to the story presented here. Basically, the king needs a new queen so they round up all the good looking virgins and he auditions them for a night until he finds the one he likes. Mordecai, the guardian of Hadassah aka Esther, goes along with this, as it's her chance to get ahead, winning the coveted title of Chief Sex Object of the Empire, and apparently it's fine with her as well. I wonder if the women of Hadassah, the U.S. Zionist women's organization, ever give a second thought to the name. I won't say more than that, people can read this for themselves.


Do keep in mind that this is not the actual historical Xerxes. That's the name the NIV translators give him, it's not the name in the Masoretic text. This is evidently a fictitious generic Achaemenid emperor and there's no independent evidence that anything like this actually happened. However, it's obviously meant to be seen as plausible by readers. 


2 Later when King Xerxes’ fury had subsided, he remembered Vashti and what she had done and what he had decreed about her. 2 Then the king’s personal attendants proposed, “Let a search be made for beautiful young virgins for the king. 3 Let the king appoint commissioners in every province of his realm to bring all these beautiful young women into the harem at the citadel of Susa. Let them be placed under the care of Hegai, the king’s eunuch, who is in charge of the women; and let beauty treatments be given to them. 4 Then let the young woman who pleases the king be queen instead of Vashti.” This advice appealed to the king, and he followed it.

5 Now there was in the citadel of Susa a Jew of the tribe of Benjamin, named Mordecai son of Jair, the son of Shimei, the son of Kish, 6 who had been carried into exile from Jerusalem by Nebuchadnezzar king of Babylon, among those taken captive with Jehoiachin[a] king of Judah. 7 Mordecai had a cousin named Hadassah, whom he had brought up because she had neither father nor mother. This young woman, who was also known as Esther, had a lovely figure and was beautiful. Mordecai had taken her as his own daughter when her father and mother died.

8 When the king’s order and edict had been proclaimed, many young women were brought to the citadel of Susa and put under the care of Hegai. Esther also was taken to the king’s palace and entrusted to Hegai, who had charge of the harem. 9 She pleased him and won his favor. Immediately he provided her with her beauty treatments and special food. He assigned to her seven female attendants selected from the king’s palace and moved her and her attendants into the best place in the harem.

10 Esther had not revealed her nationality and family background, because Mordecai had forbidden her to do so. 11 Every day he walked back and forth near the courtyard of the harem to find out how Esther was and what was happening to her.

12 Before a young woman’s turn came to go in to King Xerxes, she had to complete twelve months of beauty treatments prescribed for the women, six months with oil of myrrh and six with perfumes and cosmetics. 13 And this is how she would go to the king: Anything she wanted was given her to take with her from the harem to the king’s palace. 14 In the evening she would go there and in the morning return to another part of the harem to the care of Shaashgaz, the king’s eunuch who was in charge of the concubines. She would not return to the king unless he was pleased with her and summoned her by name.

15 When the turn came for Esther (the young woman Mordecai had adopted, the daughter of his uncle Abihail) to go to the king, she asked for nothing other than what Hegai, the king’s eunuch who was in charge of the harem, suggested. And Esther won the favor of everyone who saw her. 16 She was taken to King Xerxes in the royal residence in the tenth month, the month of Tebeth, in the seventh year of his reign.

17 Now the king was attracted to Esther more than to any of the other women, and she won his favor and approval more than any of the other virgins. So he set a royal crown on her head and made her queen instead of Vashti. 18 And the king gave a great banquet, Esther’s banquet, for all his nobles and officials. He proclaimed a holiday throughout the provinces and distributed gifts with royal liberality.

Mordecai Uncovers a Conspiracy

19 When the virgins were assembled a second time, Mordecai was sitting at the king’s gate. 20 But Esther had kept secret her family background and nationality just as Mordecai had told her to do, for she continued to follow Mordecai’s instructions as she had done when he was bringing her up.

21 During the time Mordecai was sitting at the king’s gate, Bigthana[b] and Teresh, two of the king’s officers who guarded the doorway, became angry and conspired to assassinate King Xerxes. 22 But Mordecai found out about the plot and told Queen Esther, who in turn reported it to the king, giving credit to Mordecai. 23 And when the report was investigated and found to be true, the two officials were impaled on poles. All this was recorded in the book of the annals in the presence of the king.

Footnotes

  1. Esther 2:6 Hebrew Jeconiah, a variant of Jehoiachin
  2. Esther 2:21 Hebrew Bigthan, a variant of Bigthana



Monday, July 10, 2023

Mobilization for Truth, or Survival?

Scott Frickel, of my own university, and Fernando Tormos-Aponte of the University of Pittsburgh, have recently reviewed  studies of what they call "science activism" and find that it is "surging," which they refer to as a "culture shift" among scientists. They write:

 



Sunday, July 09, 2023

Sunday Sermonette: Oink, oink

If you haven't already, please see the introduction to the Book of Esther that I posted yesterday. For Ch. 1, the main thing to keep in mind is that it is very unlikely the author intended this to be a story about the real emperor Xerxes. The Hebrew, Ahasuerus, is not the name of any actual Achaemenid emperor and we should assume that we are reading a story about a fictitious, generic emperor. That said, I would not be surprised if the real emperors, including Xerxes, were what we would consider actual sexist pigs. What we can't be sure of is how the author intended us to take Vashti's act of defiance, refusing to be paraded as a sex object. Obviously it turns out badly for her, but she must have expected that. Later Esther will make a different, pragmatic choice.


1 This is what happened during the time of Xerxes,[a] the Xerxes who ruled over 127 provinces stretching from India to Cush[b]: 2 At that time King Xerxes reigned from his royal throne in the citadel of Susa, 3 and in the third year of his reign he gave a banquet for all his nobles and officials. The military leaders of Persia and Media, the princes, and the nobles of the provinces were present.

4 For a full 180 days he displayed the vast wealth of his kingdom and the splendor and glory of his majesty. 5 When these days were over, the king gave a banquet, lasting seven days, in the enclosed garden of the king’s palace, for all the people from the least to the greatest who were in the citadel of Susa. 6 The garden had hangings of white and blue linen, fastened with cords of white linen and purple material to silver rings on marble pillars. There were couches of gold and silver on a mosaic pavement of porphyry, marble, mother-of-pearl and other costly stones. 7 Wine was served in goblets of gold, each one different from the other, and the royal wine was abundant, in keeping with the king’s liberality. 8 By the king’s command each guest was allowed to drink with no restrictions, for the king instructed all the wine stewards to serve each man what he wished.

9 Queen Vashti also gave a banquet for the women in the royal palace of King Xerxes.

10 On the seventh day, when King Xerxes was in high spirits from wine, he commanded the seven eunuchs who served him—Mehuman, Biztha, Harbona, Bigtha, Abagtha, Zethar and Karkas— 11 to bring before him Queen Vashti, wearing her royal crown, in order to display her beauty to the people and nobles, for she was lovely to look at. 12 But when the attendants delivered the king’s command, Queen Vashti refused to come. Then the king became furious and burned with anger.

13 Since it was customary for the king to consult experts in matters of law and justice, he spoke with the wise men who understood the times 14 and were closest to the king—Karshena, Shethar, Admatha, Tarshish, Meres, Marsena and Memukan, the seven nobles of Persia and Media who had special access to the king and were highest in the kingdom.

15 “According to law, what must be done to Queen Vashti?” he asked. “She has not obeyed the command of King Xerxes that the eunuchs have taken to her.”

16 Then Memukan replied in the presence of the king and the nobles, “Queen Vashti has done wrong, not only against the king but also against all the nobles and the peoples of all the provinces of King Xerxes. 17 For the queen’s conduct will become known to all the women, and so they will despise their husbands and say, ‘King Xerxes commanded Queen Vashti to be brought before him, but she would not come.’ 18 This very day the Persian and Median women of the nobility who have heard about the queen’s conduct will respond to all the king’s nobles in the same way. There will be no end of disrespect and discord.

19 “Therefore, if it pleases the king, let him issue a royal decree and let it be written in the laws of Persia and Media, which cannot be repealed, that Vashti is never again to enter the presence of King Xerxes. Also let the king give her royal position to someone else who is better than she. 20 Then when the king’s edict is proclaimed throughout all his vast realm, all the women will respect their husbands, from the least to the greatest.”

21 The king and his nobles were pleased with this advice, so the king did as Memukan proposed. 22 He sent dispatches to all parts of the kingdom, to each province in its own script and to each people in their own language, proclaiming that every man should be ruler over his own household, using his native tongue.

Footnotes

  1. Esther 1:1 Hebrew Ahasuerus; here and throughout Esther
  2. Esther 1:1 That is, the upper Nile region

Saturday, July 08, 2023

Special Saturday Bible Study: The Book of Esther

Esther requires a substantial introduction, worth a post to itself, so I figured I'd get it out of the way. It was probably written in the 4th Century BCE.  It comes here because we're following the order of the protestant Old Testament, but in the Tanakh it comes near the end. The version in the Septuagint differs considerably from the Masoretic text, and is not really considered a translation but a retelling. 


Esther is notable for a few reasons, not least that it is one of two books of the Bible that does not mention God, the other being the Song of Songs or so-called Song of Solomon. (Although Solomon almost certainly had nothing to do with it.) Despite the complete absence of any religious content, it is important to contemporary Judaism as the basis for the festival of Purim, and it is read in the synagogue during the holiday. It has obvious resonance because it is the story of a planned holocaust of the Jews, which is averted. The Jews end up turning the tables on their would-be persecutors.


It is also notable because it is probably explicitly a work of fiction. It was not meant to be taken as a historical narrative, but as what we would today call a novella. The setting is also unusual -- it takes place in the Persian capital of Shusha, during the reign of a fictitious emperor called Ahasuerus. There was no emperor of that name, so scholars and translators who were determined to conclude that this is historical fact have identified him with either Xerxes or Artaxerxes II. The translators of the New International Version, which we will be reading, call him Xerxes, maybe just because he's the most famous Achaemenid emperor, specifically because he tried and failed to conquer Greece. But we know this story is fiction because the events are preposterous, and there is no corroborating historical record.

 

Nevertheless, like all historical fiction the author does try to give the setting verisimilitude. The protagonist Esther is ethnically Jewish, but does not practice the Jewish religion, which is in fact never mentioned. The story presumes that there are many such ethnic Jews living in diaspora in the empire, who did not chose to return to Judah, and as that is also an implication in Nehemiah we can presume it to be a historical fact. It would be impossible for them to practice the Jewish religion because at the time, religious practice required proximity to the Temple. There were no synagogues, rabbis, Sabbath services or davening with a minyan. The only way to practice the religion was to participate in the sacrificial rituals at the Temple in Jerusalem, deliver the required swag to the priests, and participate in the pilgrimage festivals. If you aren't living in Judah, you can't do any of that. So the lack of mention of God is basically a fortiori. He's in the Temple. We aren't there.


Although the story depicts a couple of highly agentic women, the society it depicts is extraordinarily sexist. The extent to which the author intends to protest that can be debated, but it may be interpreted that way, along with the more obvious celebration of Jewish ethnicity and resistance -- but as a sub-national group. The book does not challenge the power or legitimacy of the emperor, nor does it refer to the province of Judah. 

 

Like I said

The high level U.S. delegation currently in China has a lot to talk about, but they're putting climate change at the top of the agenda.  As I said there's absolutely no sense driving deeper wedges between the U.S. and China. In fact the major issues are mostly about trade, global investment, and economic relations, one way or another, and those can only be resolved by deal making, not confrontation. In fact rare earths and semiconductors and photovoltaics are at the center of many of the issues so it's already about climate change. 

 

We hear absurd yelping from Republicans about how the administration  is "soft" on China, whatever that means, and should be trying to punish them for their sins. On the contrary, there's a whole lot that they want and need from us -- we have plenty of leverage, and just yelling at them (and Janet isn't yellin') or trying to find ways to punish them, which we can't possibly do without punishing ourselves, isn't going to accomplish anything. I have no illusions about Xi or the CCP, but they don't have to be nice people or folks I want to be besties with, that's irrelevant. We have a planet to save and that's all that matters.