Map of life expectancy at birth from Global Education Project.

Tuesday, September 20, 2005

Remember, you read it here first.

Well, unless you happened to read it somewhere else earlier. As we have been saying for a while now, antipsychotic drugs don't work very well, and they have really, really bad side effects. The National Institute of Mental Health funded a multi-site, head-to-head study of 5 anti-psychotic drugs, at a modest cost of just $44 million, intended to compare the newer, so-called atypical antipsychotics (brand names Zyprexa, Risperdal, Geodon and Seroquel), which bring in $10 billion a year for their manufacturers, with each other and with and older drug (brand name Trilafon), which costs a fraction as much.

You can read all about this in the newspaper -- NIMH put out a press release and it's gotten considerable coverage -- but the personalized Cervantes take on all this is that it's pretty much the same old story. The older drugs, called neuroleptics, controlled some of the most debilitating symptoms of schizophrenia, called positive symptoms -- hallucinations, delusions, disordered thinking -- and made it possible for people to function at least well enough to stay out of mental hospitals. Unfortunately, these drugs cause serious adverse effects, notably stiffness, tremors and a really bad one called tardive dyskenesia, characterized by uncontrollable repetitive movements, which can be irreversible.

So drug companies got FDA approval for the new class of antipsychotic drugs, claimed they were safer, marketed them with glowing testimonials if they did say so themselves, and charged a fortune for them. But now, says NIMH, "Contrary to expectations, movement side effects (rigidity, stiff movements, tremor and muscle restlessness) primarily associated with the older medications were not seen more frequently with pherphenazine [Trilafon] (the drug used to represent the class of older medications) . . ." And oh yeah, pherphenazine worked just as well. Zyprexa was slightly better in that fewer people taking it were hospitalized for relapses, but it was much more likely to cause serious weight gain and diabetes -- which is a potentially deadly disease. And like the other atypical antipsychotics, it costs 10 times as much as the neuroleptics.

Bottom line? We've been ripped off, again, by the drug companies with the assistance of the FDA. For people with schizophrenia and people who care about them, I'm afraid there's not a lot of good news here, except that doctors will now understand a little bit better what these drugs can and cannot do. People might as well start with the cheap ones and stay with them if they can, which will lower overall health care costs a bit. But the risk of tardive dyskenesia remains and can't be avoided. Maybe they'll find a better treatment eventually, and meanwhile, hang in there. Schizophrenia can remit in middle age. And there's a lot more we can do to help people with schizophrenia make it, especially supported housing, day treatment programs, and family centered support and respite care. There are far too many people with the disease living on the street and in shelters, and there is no excuse for that.

5 comments:

Anonymous said...

anafranil Prix en France
accutane Rezeptfrei Kaufen
Buy propecia online
achat strattera france
Order cialis
Order kamagra
plavix Online Bestellen
propecia Ohne Rezept Kaufen
viagra soft Rezeptfrei Kaufen
kamagra oral jelly Bestellen Rezeptfrei
achat xenical
acheter lovegra en france
achat accutane france
diflucan Rezeptfrei Apotheke

buy generic cialis said...

I don't trust drug companies. I feel like they are all trying to get as dumbed as if we were all living in the Huxley's "Brave New World"!

Anonymous said...

comprar Proscar sin receta
comprar Accutane sin receta
comprar Vigora sin receta
Cipro prix en pharmacie
comprar Cipro sin receta
comprare Kamagra Oral Jelly
Lasix precio
Nolvadex senza ricetta
acheter Lasix moins cher
Wellbutrin Sr vendita online
comprar Avodart sin receta
Tadalis Sx prezzo farmacia
comprar Kamagra Oral Jelly sin receta
comprare Viagra Super Active online
Apcalis Oral Jelly rezeptfrei apotheke
Lasix vendita
Celebrex senza ricetta
Synthroid comprar sin receta
Levaquin prix
Proscar prezzo farmacia
Cialis france pharmacie
Cialis Super Active discount
comprar Wellbutrin Sr sin receta
acheter Eriacta

Anonymous said...

Acheter Viagra en ligne

Achat Viagra en ligne

Anonymous said...


paypal slots
casino spokane
expansion slot definistion
play free strip blackjack
cheat kovacs laszlo roulette
surf trip slot machine
hacking device video slots
will ddr2 work in a ddr slot
applied for job at casino and didnt even get a call back
balley slot safe ram error
casino bonus no purchase required
map of all casinos in the state of washington
memory slot cards
slot machien
10 dollar blackjack and las vegas
boomtown casino verdi nevada
how do i change my blackjack 2s mtu
blackjack font
angola jackpot casino