Map of life expectancy at birth from Global Education Project.

Friday, July 06, 2007

A possible breach of medical ethics?

It's been fascinating hearing the chatter about the "Doctors' plot" terrorism case in the UK. Much punditry has focused on the cruel irony that people who have taken an oath to do no harm would be involved in such heinous acts.

Actually "do no harm" is not in the Hippocratic oath (and Cervantes busts another myth), but it would seem to be the case that attempting mass murder is inconsistent with our expectations of physicians. Alas, although I cannot say whether physicians are more likely to become mass murderers than, say, welders or medical sociologists, they are definitely likely to get away with it, and what is most notable about some of those who have been caught is the impressive totals they managed to run up before the murder did out. The Jihadi sawbones are probably most noteworthy for their incompetence, not their intentions.

The weirdest of my punditry experiences was listening to a discussion on the BBC about how appalling this all was and couldn't the National Health Service do something to screen out doctors who might be evil and so forth? This lengthy conversation managed to assiduously avoid the very recent, very notorious, and presumably highly relevant case of Harold Shipman, M.D., a veddy veddy British gentleman who murdered at least 150 of his patients and probably closer to 300. He never confessed and we don't know his motives but evidently he just enjoyed it for some reason.

Then there was Michael Swango, an American physician addicted to poisoning his patients. He also tried to poison some of his coworkers, and was caught at it -- yet he was permitted to continue practicing medicine.

Kenneth Iserson, M.D., has compiled stories of several physician mass murderers. Again, what they tend to have in common is an extraordinary ability to get away with it, because of relevant skill and guile, assisted by physicians' high social status and cultural reluctance to question their judgment and actions. A couple of these cases are of doctors who were carrying out the policies of depraved political leadership, in Iserson's book the grotesque human experiments conducted in imperial Japan, and of course the comparable Nazi experiments are somewhat better known in the U.S. (I'm not sure why.) But that's a somewhat different case.

Please do not become paranoid. Such anti-doctors are, of course, one in a million. Most of the docs I know really, deeply, sincerely care about their patients and want to honor their profession. The worst of them really, deeply, sincerely care about money and want to be rich and adored, but murdering people is generally not conducive to those goals.

What is particularly noteworthy about the UK terrorist docs is that, in spite of their evident hatred for Britons in the collective and abstract, and their indifference to human life, there is no indication, at least so far, that they did not practice medicine in an exemplary manner. If killing people was what it was all about, they could have emulated Dr. Shipman and done it quietly for years. But that, obviously, it is not the point of so-called terrorism, which is a public action intended to draw maximum attention. Murder is just a means to that end, and it wouldn't surprise me if, in their professional lives, they would have found the idea of harming patients appalling and impossible. Humans are weird, that's for sure.

7 comments:

viagra online said...

Wow... this can't be, the medical staff shout do psychological testing more deeply and also make them every month to all doctors and about ethics well sometimes good doctors go to prison for not take chances, but doctors should save lives, not kill patients.

Generic Viagra said...

Nowadays is very common to heard about this situations, but most of the time Doctors who go to prison are the doctors that work at the goverment hospitals, is not common to see private doctors at jail. Great review you got here.

Anonymous said...

zithromax Kaufen
Kaufen kamagra oral jelly Online
proscar Rezeptfrei Kaufen
kamagra Rezeptfrei Kaufen
viagra Bestellen
acheter diflucan pas cher
Buy strattera
zithromax Rezept
cipro Online Rezept
viagra soft Bestellen
cialis soft Ohne Rezept Bestellen
zithromax Kaufen

www.muebles-en-arganda-del-rey.com said...

This can't have effect in actual fact, that's exactly what I believe.

Roxana said...

So, I do not really suppose this is likely to work.

Anonymous said...


Viagra Prix
Viagra Pharmacie

Anonymous said...


free roulette powerpoint template
power blackjack heller pdf
bai lu vietnam resort hotel gaming casino
hollywood casino employment
10 best casino online top
igt slots video game
free casino play for fun
bosier city casinos
virtual casino
poker onlinegambling crapsonline roulette
faster slot machine play
vintage slot car track
tropicana casino in laughhlin nv
blackjack roulette system casino
seminole hard rock casino
casino empire cheats
slot cars danbury ct
list of casinos in oklahoma
top online gaming sites
pictures of las vegas casinos
game of roulette