Map of life expectancy at birth from Global Education Project.

Wednesday, January 07, 2009

Disease, sickness, illness, disorder, condition . . .

First of all, I should acknowledge that Kathy A. is basically right, I was a bit sloppy with my vocabulary. ASPD is a pretty vague and often circular diagnosis that can be applied to anybody who badly misbehaves; what I really meant to defend is the much more specific, and rare, label of psychopathy. What I meant to say is that the diagnostic label should be reserved for people who truly lack the capacity for empathy.

So let's back up a bit. In medicine, diseases are usually defined in terms of an etiological process. Similar symptoms may be ascribed to completely different diseases, e.g. infection by different viruses; while people with no subjective symptoms may be given a diagnosis because of some biological fact which is believed to create a risk for illness (the subjective experience of poor health) in the future, e.g. HIV infection or hypercholesterolemia. Physicians generally don't like to call clusters of symptoms without a known etiology diseases, rather they call them syndromes, and they tend to argue about the ontological status of such entities. Good examples are fibromyalgia and chronic fatigue syndrome.

In psychiatry, however, etiology is generally unknown. Practitioners like to tell stories about causation but they are usually poorly supported by evidence. Drug companies also market theories about biological causes of DSM-defined diseases but these are largely mendacious. For example, they have convinced most people that a disease called depression is caused by a deficiency of the neurotransmitter serotonin, but this is almost certainly false. The evidence for this is supposedly that drugs which increase serotonin levels alleviate depression, but even if that were true -- which it is not for the large majority of people diagnosed with depression -- it would not demonstrate that depression is caused by serotonin deficiency. Amphetamines cause people not to feel hungry even when they don't eat, but that doesn't mean that the cause of hunger is amphetamine deficiency, even less that the solution to hunger is amphetamines.

The DSM entities are defined by symptoms, mostly consisting of descriptions of behaviors, not by etiology. Since human behavior is continuously variable, highly flexible, highly complex, and mutable, it's very hard to rigorously sort people into behavioral buckets. Generally speaking, only the most stereotypical, rigid and simple kinds of behaviors can be measured unambiguously. For example, Tourette's Syndrome has a strong ontological claim, because we can say quite definitely whether or not a person has an uncontrollable, repetitive behavior of injecting inappropriate words into conversation. But those sorts of entities are usually thought of as neurological rather than psychiatric, and once a definite etiology is discovered, they cease to be the province of psychiatry at all.

So, now I hope I've cleared the decks enough to discuss BPD. My basic reason for wanting to do so is to argue that it is not entirely feckless to look for psychodynamic explanations for emotional and behavioral problems, and that perhaps there is a coherent story to be told about "normal" human personality development and the ways in which the social environment can derail it. We need a definition of "normal" in order to say that, and in fact the word has multiple meanings. But it can mean more than just whatever the culture currently happens to find morally meritorious, or whatever happens to be most common. In both those respects, homosexuality used to be abnormal, as it still is for some people, and probably always will be in the latter respect. But I mean to argue that BPD is different.

12 comments:

kathy a. said...

very interested in what you have to say. and, as you probably guessed, i think there is a world of difference between homosexuality and BPD.

Discover What You Think said...

The Shrink's bible has been around for over 50 years, and now possibly contains nearly 300 mental disorders. Published by the APA, it is also used, I understand, for mental diagnostic criteria to assure reimbursement as well as to validate suspected assessments by the psychiatrist and is organized by the following:

I- Mental disorders
II- mental conditions
III- Physical disorders/syndromes, medical conditions (co-morbidity)
IV- Mental disorder suspected etiology
V- Pediatric assessments

The next DSM, DSM-V, has had its task force members sign non-disclosure agreements, which is rather absurd. Lack of transparency equals lack of credibility because of these agreements of the content of the next DSM. It opposes any recovery model necessary regarding such disorders, I believe.

The DSM should be evaluated by another unrelated task force to assure objectivity. In its history, the DSM has had created diagnoses removed as well, such as classifying homosexuality as a mental dysfunction until 1973,

Dan Abshear





________________________________________
New year...new news. Be the first to know what is making headlines.

hi mik1986 said...

Today, there are countless medications to treat depression, even the severe forms. But before starting any medicine one must consult a doctor and take his advice on the matter. If you feel that you have clinical depression symptoms, you should talk to your doctor about depression, anxiety medications that can lift the cloud and get you back to life. http://www.buy-xanax-online now.com
http://www.buy-xanax-online-now.com

seller said...

very good post

buy cialis said...

are diseases that impair the wrong people, from young people living with a disease according to the blog, this is so, I agree with it

Isma said...

Hello .. firstly I would like to send greetings to all readers. After this, I recognize the content so interesting about this article. For me personally I liked all the information. I would like to know of cases like this more often. In my personal experience I might mention a book called Generic Viagra in this book that I mentioned have very interesting topics, and also you have much to do with the main theme of this article.

viagra in uk said...

Thanks for your useful advice.

Anonymous said...

plavix Rezeptfrei Bestellen
amoxil Online Rezept
Achat inderal Sans Ordonnance
lovegra Kaufen Apotheke
priligy Ohne Rezept Kaufen
strattera Rezeptfrei Apotheke
diflucan acheter en ligne
strattera Bestellen Rezeptfrei
Ohne Rezept strattera
viagra soft Kaufen Apotheke
kamagra Bestellen Rezeptfrei
cialis soft Internet Bestellen
strattera Online Bestellen

generic cialis said...

yeah maybe you right but this deppends not just about the region, it's about health systems, education and many other factors.

ativan success stories said...

I thinks there is no drugs that can help

Anonymous said...

Viagra prix
comprare Plavix online
Diflucan sin receta espaƱa
Levitra comprar
Flagyl senza ricetta in farmacia
Suhagra senza ricetta
Tadacip senza ricetta in farmacia
Silagra senza ricetta
achat Clomid
Cialis prix
Cialis Professional senza ricetta in farmacia
Priligy comprar sin receta
Cialis Professional prix
Viagra vendita online
Zovirax prix
Proscar prix discount
Apcalis Oral Jelly comprar sin receta
Vigora prix discount
Amoxil vendita online
Priligy rezeptfrei
prezzo Cialis
Zovirax vendita online
achat Keflex
Avodart sin receta en farmacias
Propecia rezeptfrei apotheke
acheter Viagra Super Active sans ordonnance
acheter Silagra sans ordonnance
Neurontin prix discount

Anonymous said...


Prix Viagra France

Acheter Viagra en ligne