Map of life expectancy at birth from Global Education Project.

Friday, October 16, 2009

Civil War

The Commonwealth Fund recently came out with its annual state scorecard on health system performance. You may be interested in seeing how your own state is doing. It is instructive, first of all, that since we do not have any effective national policy to shape health care system performance, the variation among the states is enormous. You will not see this in civilized countries that have coherent national health care systems.

But I particularly want to draw your attention to Exhibit One, (click to enlarge) which shows an overall ranking of the states. Notice any patterns there? What do you think would happen if we colored those states red and blue depending on the likelihood that their senators will vote for national health care reform? Of the bottom ten, only Illinois gets a gold star. Of the top ten, South Dakota and Nebraska get a split, although we'll have to see what Ben Nelson ends up doing; Joe Lieberman might be a no vote but he doesn't represent his state; and Maine is likely a no although Sen. Snowe is still teasing us. Otherwise, they're all on board.

The picture is more mixed in the middle, and this picture interacts with population density, regional culture and other factors that influence both politics and health system quality. Still, the states with the worst health care systems are the least likely to have elected representatives who support change, while the states with the best systems are mostly for it. Why do you think that is?

5 comments:

Michael said...

I subscribe and receive your blog via gmail, which gets me some deliciously ironic ads and links through their keyword approach. Here's the article that came up on the banner above this post:
http://www.imaginewhatif.com/2009/09/reform-means-higher-costs-not-lower.html?gclid=CNHBlZfQw50CFdVL5Qod-DTKrQ#more

Vile

Bix said...

Wow. Those are real disparities.

Cervantes said...

Yeah Michael, it's amusing to go to liberal sites like Talking Points Memo and see ads for Michelle Malkin books and so on. The bots look for keywords, I think, but they aren't intelligent.

Custom Term Papers said...

Nice post. I really liked it.. Don't forget to update it regularly. I am looking for new updates dying to read more stuff from you.

Term Papers said...

I really enjoyed reading this blog. These types blogs will encourage our self to get knowledge about this types. Thanks looking for more good techniques..and thanks for sharing this most important information.....


Term papers